Choose a dozen. Or two. Or ten.

Our three Favorites Assortments (Classic, Seasonal and Chocolate) are always available tomorrow morning (order by 5 p.m.).

You can also mix and match any of our flavors. Just make sure you place your order at least 48 hours in advance.

Done drooling? Order online, anytime. Or find us at any of these retail locations.

*certain flavors contain nuts

  • Classic Favorites

    • The Plain Jane

      Vanilla cake, vanilla buttercream, and a Dutch white chocolate garnish

    • The Cinnful Apple

      Vanilla cake, baked apple filling, creamy cinnamon buttercream, and sweet cinnamon sugar sprinkles

    • Southern Belle
      Traditional red velvet cake, smooth cream cheese frosting, and sweet red sugar sprinkles
    • Pretzella*
      Chocolate cake, nutella buttercream, and a crunchy crushed pretzel topping
    • PB No J*

      Chocolate cake, peanut butter buttercream, and a ground peanut garnish

    • Cheeseberry
      Vanilla cake, blueberry filling, cream cheese buttercream frosting, and a dried blueberry garnish

  • Seasonal Favorites

    • Snickerdoodle

      Vanilla cake, cinnamon buttercream, and a dusting of cinnamon sugar

    • Chicago Pothole Rocky Road*

      Chocolate cake, marshmallow buttercream, toasted pecans, and a drizzle of our homemade chocolate ganache

    • Bitter Chocolate Orange

      Coming soon!

      Chocolate cake, orange-infused buttercream, and hand-chopped bitter dark chocolate shavings

    • Birthday Cake

      Vanilla cake, a swirl of fresh vanilla buttercream, and rainbow sprinkles

    • Bella Nutella*

      Vanilla cake, cherry berry filling, chocolate Nutella buttercream, and chocolate curls

    • Bananarama

      Vanilla cake, a swirl of brown butter buttercream, our homemade caramel, and a dried banana garnish

  • Chocolate Favorites

    • Partners in Crime
      Moist chocolate cake, cookies and cream buttercream, and a light dusting of Oreo crumbs
    • Ooey Gooey
      Chocolate cake, caramel filling, caramel buttercream, ganache topping, and a pinch of sea salt
    • Minted
      Chocolate cake, mint chocolate chip buttercream, and a European chocolate garnish
    • Give Me S'Mores
      Chocolate cake, marshmallow cream filling and buttercream, and a dainty ganache marshmallow and graham cracker crumb topping
    • Everybody Loves Chocolate
      Chocolate cake, real Dutch chocolate buttercream, and a Dutch white chocolate garnish
    • Caffeine Fix
      Chocolate cake, espresso buttercream, and a dainty Dutch chocolate coffee bean garnish